Shame on the Labour Party. Despite Starmer’s refrain of putting country before party, it has done the opposite. In stabbing Starmer in the back wholly unnecessarily, we have a zombie government led by a zombie prime minister at a time of national peril (Ukraine, Iran etc). Labour is simply no longer fit for office whoever leads it. This situation could go on for months if Starmer is determined not to stand down.
And what a motley crew of candidates seeking to replace him. The hugely overrated Burnham versus ‘I have just blown up my career’ Streeting versus the preposterous Rayner or incredible Ed ‘failed last time but that shouldn’t count’ Miliband.
None of them are fundamentally up to the job…
The favourite, assuming he survives a Reform by-election challenge in Makerfield, is Burnham. Why? Manchester’s success is largely down to the actions of the former Leader and Chief Executive of Manchester City Council not the mayor. Burnham’s national policy pronouncements are also hardly impressive; rowing back on blowing up the bond markets or watering down any urge to embrace the EU. He wants to renationalise a swathe of industries and will undoubtedly move the Labour government to the Left although further delegation of powers to the regions does makes sense. He is not a details man.
Burnham will make no meaningful difference to Labour’s fortunes except to at least initially be less unpopular than Starmer. One doubts he will overcome the electorate’s frustration over the chaos at the heart of government.
It is a common belief that the beneficiary of all this is Reform but I don’t agree. Farage has his own troubles and not just the investigation into a £5 million gift. He has a natural ceiling of support which is not far from where his party is now and the current mayhem presents a clear opportunity for the Tories if they were willing to take it. Badenoch has performed well recently and should make sure the Conservative Party contests Makerfield vigorously despite the certain wipeout.
The Tories then need to remake their case for economic competence stating clearly how they would manage public expenditure, introduce business friendly policies and realistically talk about tax aims. The conversation with voters must be clear and honest and include accepting responsibility for past mistakes and perhaps hinting at greater cooperation with the EU, starting with defence which is surely palatable to all Tories… Ultimately, ‘it’s the economy, stupid’ should be their one and only refrain since Labour under a Burnham government or Reform under a Farage government would both be reckless financially. It will still take a good while for the electorate to warm to the Tories of course after their incompetent past but at least Labour is now in the same boat!
The gap in today’s British politics is ideal for a centre-right party to differentiate itself with policies that reward aspiration whilst firmly but sensitively reducing the size of the state. Are the Tories disciplined enough to do this in the face of populism? Today, I doubt it but one lives in hope…
Inside Right Politics 