The Windrush scandal may be the final straw. It is not the unfolding story of Home Office excess in itself which leads you to reach this conclusion but the overall anti-immigration narrative emanating from a Tory government for too long.
Fearful of the threat from UKIP, immigration scare stories fed the Brexit debate, poisoned public discourse and have led to where we are today – a meaner, more inward looking country too often driven by the lowest common denominator. Many Tory Brexiteers are responsible for this. Enthused by a genuinely liberal interpretation of the ‘take back control’ agenda they allied, however inadvertently, with a darker narrative. Cameron gambled recklessly with his referendum, playing fast and loose with the country’s future for Party advantage. He failed. What an epitaph…
How did the Tory Party get here? The origins started with Margaret Thatcher who made the Party ideological. This approach freed it from the complacent, cliquey Tory Left and was arguably beneficial to the country for many years, but has potentially sowed the seeds for its own destruction.
Consensus in the Tory Party is now a dirty word. Leaving the EU completely is consequently its new Corn Laws. The Party is too full of careerists, accused of pursuing the agenda of its ever diminishing right-wing membership for advancement, free from the desire for any real statesmanship. John Major and Michael Heseltine are today derided by their own so-called colleagues. Unthinkable in an earlier age.
The current leader and Prime Minister is deeply unimaginative and frankly not as up to the job as hoped. High expectations have been dashed. She was meant to be moderate and has turned out to be passively extreme. The writings about her political advisers and their outrageous treatment of colleagues in her early PM days simply confirm this.
Speaking to a leading Conservative supporting commentator recently he sadly admitted he would never join the Tory Party today but can’t leave after 40 years of tribalism. Many know how he feels!
The Tories get away with it currently because of the sheer awfulness of the Opposition. For that reason alone, Theresa May will probably survive. When will Labour supporters wake up to this? Politics is simply debased by, at best, the sheer mediocrity on offer from both sides, most of the greatness of the major parties vanquished.
The future? Not the Tory Party as it is except by default – supposedly driven by the rumoured 70k membership, average age 72. Nor extremist Labour. Is a takeover of the ineffectual Liberal Democrats or a new party (watch ‘Renew’ in the local elections in Wandsworth) the answer? Or, ever hopeful, a brave new Tory leader who will rescue the Party and broader political discourse from the abyss?